Happening Now

Loading...

Wednesday, August 18, 2010

Lost Causes



In prepping for the day ahead I was watching a clip from my favorite film of all time Mr. Smith Goes to Washington. In the final scene, an exhausted Senator Smith uses the last of his strength to remind one of his colleagues that "Lost causes are sometimes the only ones worth fighting for."

Earlier this morning I encountered a woman who was homeless who had split her head open on a tree stump in one of our parks. Bleeding, she came to the closest open restaurant and begged them to call the paramedics. The workers, who spoke broken English, came and asked my friend if he could speak to the 911 operator. As we went to see the woman, who was at the drive through window, I realized that she was one of the speakers at last night's council meeting.

The woman at the meeting was quite distraught about the level of harassment she felt she was getting from local police and the lack of help she was getting from the community. According to her she had reached out for help and no one cared to even try. Seeing her speak and later her daughter, broke my heart. Her story was all over the place, but I could hear in her very emotionally-charged address some things that very well could have happened including things like police harassment.

So there she was crying, with blood dripping down the right side of her face and onto her shirt and next to her was her son, who looked about 15 and was extremely pale. With paramedics on the way she asked if one of us could buy her son something to eat as he had, according to her, not eaten in two days. So my friend did, and purchased him a hamburger. The paramedics arrived, cleaned the wound and took her and her son to the hospital for what I assume would be a few stitches.

Remembering the council meeting I had remembered that the woman came with her daughter, who was about my age, to address the council. So I spoke to my friend and we set out to find where the daughter was to attempt to give her the number of a community resource she could take advantage of. We found her wrapped in a blanket at the edge of the park with a shopping cart filled with, what I assume to be the family's last few items that they owned and I gave her the number. She initially wouldn't even respond to me. I told her where I had recognized her from and explained that there are a lot of people who do care and told her to call the number for some help. She reluctantly took the number and we left.

I can't tell you how much the entire situation pulled on my heart. I do not know the background of this woman and her family but what I do know is that the daughter, who was left alone, had a look on her face that I will never forget. She didn't have much but most of what she did have left was taken away in an ambulance minutes earlier. She was left there with a shopping cart filled with a few personal effects of the family and no direction for the day ahead. It was horrifying and with a sense of helplessness I got in my car and went home.

 As an individual who is involved in this community, it is all too often easy to sing the praises of all the programs we have for people who are in need. We, in this community, tend to be satisfied with the safety net we have created and tend to be dismissive of those who have fallen through it. The Mayberry mentality we all enjoy allows us to rationalize away the down-right horrifying reality of the volume of people who are and who will continue to fall through our safety nets. We should not and cannot be satisfied.

While I acknowledge that we will never be able to help every homeless family or feed every starving individual in our community, I do believe that we need to evaluate our safety net when it so clearly failed. At the council meeting the woman stated that she asked for help, she stated that she reached out to BTAC and that nothing could be done to help her. Sad part is, I believe her. I don't know why BTAC would have turned her away but I hear from more and more people who have requested aid with there water and power bill (which is a program run through BTAC) that they have been turned away. Maybe demand is high? I don't know.

These are obviously tough times but we who are blessed to be in leadership positions cannot afford to be dismissive of everyday residents who are now struggling to survive. In a matter of a few hours this woman's situation went from bad to worse. No one on the council or on staff cared enough to pick up a phone and give anyone of our local hotels a call. The nightmare of what happened and what will happen when child protective services gets involved, as a result of last night, was easily preventable.

In the end I just want to say this. We as leaders in this community and as good human beings have a responsibility to look out for members of our community. Let us not forget that we are empowered to listen and then act rather than act and then listen. And lastly, let us also not forget that every human being has an inherent value and so does their opinion. We have lost this in Burbank and while I may be an idealist I hope this is not a lost cause. But hey, as Mr. Smith said, "Lost causes are sometimes the only ones worth fighting for."

12 comments:

  1. Lost causes are the most important causes to fight for. Infact so long as good people are willing to fight for what is right the cause is not lost at all. Look at Nazi Germany and all the executions that took place. If only good people had stood up against the odds for the lost causes history might be very different.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Steve,

    Great but difficult post. However, I strongly disagree with your assertion that we can't feed every starving member of our community. Our tough times can't be an excuse for government inaction, it must be a call to action. Now is the time for civic leaders to truly prioritize. The key needs of a government are not to grant officials pay raises, but to ensure that the people are safe and at the very least not starving in the streets. Even if people only want to act out of self interest, the farther we let our neighbors fall the harder it will be for all of us to rise up when the good times return.

    Keep up the good work.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Most certainly the very least the government can do is stop making things worse. High salaries by public servants and rate increases to keep up the spending is making things worse. We may see lawns that are brown and dead but imagine people inside their homes in this heat unable to even afford air conditioning. Can you spell possible heat stroke and death ?

    Government leaders are busy munching caviar while the people they reprsent struggle just to survive.

    They bail out big developers but what help do they give to the average citizens ? They freeze social security cost of living increases yet raise the cost of everything. They raid retirement funds while they give themselves 90% of their salary when they retire.

    Government officials are failing and they are doing it miserably.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Devin,

    Fully agree with you. The truth is in good times the peopple are taxed and support the government. That must be recripocal in bad times. It is time for leaders to step up, make changes in their spending and help out those who have always supported the world by paying taxes. Those officials who only want to take and take must be removed.

    ReplyDelete
  5. You would have thought that someone from the non-profits present at last nights Council meeting (Family Services, Burbank Housing Corp.) would have reached out to help the woman. She needs to contact Family Promise for temp. housing through one of our participating local Churches. Surprised BTAC didn't refer her. Glad God put you in the right place at the right time to lend some help; you did a lot more than our useless Mayor & Council who just dished out big raises to BWP Exec's.

    ReplyDelete
  6. OMG, this is a horrible story. I am so sorry for this woman and her family. There may be more to the story about how her house was taken away from her, if she was only 2 months behind on her mortgage, it does not make sense.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Mayor Renkie, Councilman Jess and Councilman Golonski talk a lot but when it comes down to helping someone that comes and begs them for help they just shove the person aside and say go away. This poor woman and her kids got shoved away and out the door because they don't count with these people. Councilman Golonski talks and talks about non profits but when it comes to really helping anyone he is the first to kick them right out the door.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Steve,

    I simply cannot believe that you wrote this drivel.

    That woman that you write about is obviously severely emotionally challenged. To be politically incorrect, she is crazy as a bed bug.

    How convenient for you to write this tendentious column whose only purpose that I can detect is a grab for attention.

    You don't bother to mention her repeated claims that various govt agencies, the police, sheriffs, courts, the city council, had broken into her home and altered her home loan documents, do you?

    How did you miss that? How did you miss reporting that she claims that the police have been surreptitiously in her home on many occasions. How do you miss out her obvious delusions and hysteria?

    This unfortunate woman has lost the ability to live productively in the real world, she cannot hold down a job, and no longer has an income sufficient to pay her mortgage.

    That is all tragic, and clearly she and her kids need help. But your column is an insult to the city council and the various agencies in Burbank that could perhaps help her. She is one step short of a raving lunatic and you are exploiting her tragedy to burnish your own image as a do-gooder. You should be ashamed.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I really disagree and I am not ashamed.

    In my column I stated that her comments at the council meeting "were all over the place." I agree and believe that she is indeed not all there and needs some help but at the council meeting she was reaching out for THAT VERY HELP. She felt ignored and abused by the system and whether or not that is the reality it was very much her reality. And what happened at the council meeting on Tuesday? She was ignored again.

    I know the council members to be charitable people who have, and continue to support countless numbers of charity groups in our community. That is why it was so frustrating to watch. Anyone of our council members could have secured housing for her for the evening if they wanted to. It was the lack of charity shown by who I know to be charitable people that frustrated me. Charity that should have been coordinated if not for her sake then for the sake of her two kids. A lack of mental sanity on an individual's part does not eliminate their need for humanity and compassion.

    I also cannot bring myself to appreciate the usage of the word lunatic in the comment. Does the usage of that term suddenly make her less of a person? Is it okay now to ignore her needs as a human being? In this city and in this society we are so quick to label people in an effort to justify a reason to dismiss their input in our governmental process altogether. This woman is not a lunatic. This woman is mother of two children who is homeless and in need of some help. That is the very sad reality that the term lunatic so frivolously dismisses.

    As for the "do-gooder" comment. Yes, I try everyday to be a good human being. That is what my faith expects of me and that is what this country expects of me. This blog and this post is not about burnishing my own image this simply is a recording of my own opinions about different things in government and politics, and an attempt to notify the small readership of this blog of the very real problem of homelessness in our community. I have a right to my opinion and right to disagree, and yes, even with the council and I would hope that they as trustees of our local democracy would respect that right.

    Thank you again for your comment. As you can see I strongly disagree with you but I support the right you have as an individual in this community to have it. Again, thank you for taking the time to come to my blog.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Steve,

    Get a grip. You may believe we live in Oz and the wizzard at City Hall provides the best in services but if you take off the rose colored glasses reality sets in.

    ReplyDelete
  11. There is nothing wrong with believing that it is the job of society and it's government to help those suffering and in need.

    I applaud for extrapolating that very important point from the experience with the woman and her family.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Jeff Prutz

    I'm waiting for someone to come out and tell us how many single family homes could be built with all the money we "saved" if we put all the crazy people on the trains to "treatment" centers.

    Some people in Burbank might hope to undermine the efforts of those who believe we have an obligation to care for those who can not care for themselves, but it's a step too far to say that Steven had personal gain on his mind when he wrote this.

    ReplyDelete